At Badger Fulfillment Group we have always believed that understanding your competitive landscape is just as important as knowing your own strengths. Our roots are deeply planted in the world of ecommerce and subscription box fulfillment and our focus remains on delivering seamless service with a high level of customization and care. We operate as an extension of your brand ensuring that every order reflects the quality and consistency your customers expect. But not every 3PL provider shares the same priorities or structure. In fact, the Chicagoland region is home to a wide variety of fulfillment and logistics companies each offering something very different from what we provide.
This diversity is a clear signal that not all 3PLs are created equal. Some focus on large scale freight brokerage while others specialize in cold chain logistics or high-volume B2B warehousing. These are valuable services for businesses with industrial or wholesale distribution needs, but they do not speak to the curated high touch experience we create for our clients. By taking a closer look at these differences we hope to provide clarity for brands who are weighing their options and seeking a fulfillment partner that understands the distinct demands of modern ecommerce and subscription delivery.
Badger Fulfillment Group
Badger Fulfillment Group was founded with a singular focus to elevate the fulfillment experience for ecommerce brands and subscription box companies. Our team operates from a centralized Midwest location providing nationwide reach while ensuring that each client benefits from hands-on account management and deep integration with their systems. Our facility and processes are built to support agility high-touch service and rapid scalability making us a strategic partner for growing brands that require more than just order processing. Our clients value the direct line of communication and the genuine collaboration that defines every fulfillment project we take on.
Strengths
- Deep specialization in subscription box and ecommerce fulfillment
- Dedicated account managers operating directly from within the warehouse
- Seamless technology integrations with popular ecommerce platforms
- Custom kitting and packaging options for brand consistency
- Centralized location for fast and cost-effective shipping across the US
Key Considerations
- May not be the best fit for brands that prioritize cost-cutting over service quality and responsiveness
- Not designed for industrial scale pallet storage
- Tailored services may not align with businesses seeking commoditized low-touch fulfillment
What They Do Best
Badger Fulfillment Group excels at helping fast-growing ecommerce and subscription brands scale without sacrificing quality. By aligning closely with each client’s brand and operational needs Badger provides more than just logistics support. It delivers a true partnership grounded in precision communication and performance that consistently exceeds expectations.
Red Stag Fulfillment
Red Stag Fulfillment was built for a specific kind of challenge, one that involves heavy oversized or high-value products that demand extra care. From its national fulfillment centers Red Stag serves ecommerce merchants that sell products most 3PLs shy away from including furniture, fitness equipment and other bulky SKUs. Their operational model is centered around precision, handling secure facilities and specialized packaging processes that ensure even the most cumbersome shipments arrive safely and efficiently. This high standard of execution has made them a standout for brands where weight and size are mission-critical factors.
Strengths
• Expertise in handling heavy, bulky and high-value items
• Error rate below industry averages with guaranteed accuracy policies
• Secure warehouse environment with advanced surveillance and restricted access
• Scalable infrastructure with a focus on operational excellence
• Transparent service level agreements that prioritize performance accountability
Key Considerations
- Not optimized for high-SKU count lightweight pick-pack operations
- May be cost-prohibitive for startups or lower-margin products
- Limited kitting or subscription box services
What They Do Best
Red Stag Fulfillment thrives where most 3PLs hesitate. For businesses shipping oversized goods or products requiring white-glove handling their facilities processes and guarantees are tailored to deliver confidence at scale. They offer a fulfillment experience that balances precision with protection making them a trusted partner for high-weight ecommerce categories.
Amsco Prep
Amsco Prep is a specialized 3PL and Amazon FBA prep center based in Huntley, Illinois. They support ecommerce brands by handling everything from inbound inspection and FNSKU labeling to poly-bagging bubble wrapping case forwarding and inventory live updates. Their proximity to Amazon distribution centers and integration with Seller Central makes them a pick for brands relying heavily on Amazon channels.
Strengths
- Full-service Amazon FBA prep with API-linked FNSKU labelling
- Fast 24–72 hour turnaround time with real-time inventory updates
- No minimums accommodating both small sellers and high-volume brands
- Poly-bagging bubble wrapping kitting and bundle services included
- Located near Amazon hubs offering cost-effective forwarding to FBA
Key Considerations
- Highly Amazon-centric less focus on non-Amazon DTC or subscription workflow
- Pricing structure is per-ASIN which may not align with flat-rate fulfillment models
- Less suited for brands wanting high-touch kitting or custom packaging beyond FBA specs
What They Do Best
Amsco Prep excels in preparing Amazon-bound inventory quickly and accurately. Their tight integration with Seller Central and streamlined labelling workflows mean products hit FBA faster than if done in-house or through Amazon’s own prep services. Their model is ideal for Amazon-native sellers who prioritize speed to marketplace and compliance with Amazon’s rigorous prep standards.
G10 Fulfillment
G10 Fulfillment is a tech-enabled 3PL with a strong focus on compliant hazmat handling. G10 is fully equipped to store, package and ship hazardous materials including flammable liquids, aerosols, lithium batteries and chemicals. Their facilities are certified for DOT, EPA, OSHA and CFATS compliance. They operate a dedicated hazmat fulfillment center and use proprietary technology called ChannelPoint to manage integrations, inventory and shipping operations efficiently.
Strengths
- Certified hazmat handling in compliance with DOT, EPA, OSHA and CFATS
- Dedicated hazmat-trained staff and secure warehouse zones
- Competitive hazmat shipping rates and strategic warehouse locations to lower costs
- ChannelPoint integration connects to Amazon, Walmart, Wayfair, Target and more
- High performance track record with a very high on-time fulfillment rate
Key Considerations
- Focused on hazmat and multi-channel retail with less alignment for tailored kits or premium packaging
- Operational costs may be higher than general ecommerce providers due to specialized compliance
- May require minimum volumes and integration work for non-hazmat clients
What They Do Best
G10 thrives in scenarios where stringent regulatory compliance is essential. They offer a turnkey hazmat solution that handles storage, regulatory updates, complex labeling and safe transportation. Their secure facilities and trained personnel ensure that dangerous goods are processed with unmatched reliability. It is a level of service that complements rather than competes with Badger FG’s consumer-centered fulfillment model.
United Facilities
United Facilities has built its legacy around long-term partnerships with industrial and automotive clients. With roots in Illinois and facilities spread across the Midwest and beyond they operate large-scale contract warehousing and value-added services like light assembly repackaging and vendor managed inventory. Their model is designed to support enterprise-level B2B operations that require consistency, control and the ability to scale with complex supply chain requirements. For brands with industrial product lines or OEM distribution needs United delivers high-volume throughput and deep supply chain integration.
Strengths
- Longstanding experience in industrial automotive and B2B logistics
- Multiple warehouse campuses with high-capacity racking and staging
- Strong capabilities in vendor managed inventory and assembly services
- Well-suited for national manufacturers requiring bulk movement and control
- Deep investment in client-specific warehouse engineering and integration
Key Considerations
- Not built for high-touch consumer packaging or small-parcel DTC fulfillment
- Technology and processes optimized for enterprise workflows not ecommerce storefronts
- Less agility for smaller brands or those requiring personalized brand presentation
What They Do Best
United Facilities delivers at scale for companies with demanding B2B logistics requirements. Their strength lies in consistency across long-term programs where performance reliability and process depth matter most. Their industrial focus makes them an ideal fit for manufacturers and wholesalers.
ODW Logistics
ODW Logistics operates from its Kenosha, Wisconsin facility with a clear emphasis on end-to-end supply chain execution for B2B clients. Their expertise spans contract logistics, transportation and data-driven supply chain planning. ODW is particularly well suited for mid-sized to large manufacturers and distributors that require scalable warehousing with integrated transportation solutions.
Strengths
- Integrated warehousing and transportation with engineered workflows
- Strong focus on B2B distribution and manufacturer support
- Facility locations that serve national retail and wholesale networks
- Dedicated team for continuous improvement and cost control
- Deep reporting and forecasting capabilities to support operational planning
Key Considerations
- Not designed for high-volume consumer parcel fulfillment
- Limited in-house branding or custom packaging capabilities
- Operational tempo and systems best suited for longer lead-time supply chains
What They Do Best
ODW Logistics performs best when serving as an extension of a client’s industrial or wholesale operation. They bring structure efficiency and performance accountability to businesses that value throughput and scale over individualized parcel experiences. Their engineered approach to logistics supports organizations that need stable fulfillment solutions aligned to long-range planning and inventory control.
ID Logistics
ID Logistics formerly known as Kane Logistics operates a regional hub in Kenosha, Wisconsin and serves the food beverage and consumer packaged goods industries. They specialize in cold chain fulfillment regulated inventory handling and high-volume retail distribution. Their facilities are designed for efficiency with a focus on meeting strict compliance standards and managing perishable or temperature-sensitive items. For brands needing reliable large-scale storage and movement across national retail networks ID Logistics brings the infrastructure and systems needed for streamlined execution.
Strengths
- Deep expertise in cold chain and food-grade fulfillment
- Retail distribution to major outlets including club stores and national grocers
- Inventory systems tailored for expiration tracking and regulatory compliance
- Proven capabilities in rapid high-volume distribution
- Scalable programs for enterprise-level brands with seasonal or promotional surges
Key Considerations
- Limited capabilities in subscription box services or direct-to-consumer customization
- Packaging flexibility may be constrained by warehouse automation and throughput goals
- Primarily built to serve enterprise clients with high minimum volumes and long planning cycles
What They Do Best
ID Logistics is a top choice for brands with sensitive products that require a high level of control across warehousing and transportation. Their strength lies in the ability to meet compliance requirements and maintain product integrity through cold chain solutions and operational discipline.
Hub Group
Hub Group, based in Oak Brook, Illinois is a nationally recognized leader in transportation management and intermodal logistics. Their strength lies in moving freight not in storing or packaging it. Hub provides large-scale managed transportation services including rail drayage and truckload optimization for enterprise shippers across North America. Their proprietary platforms and data-driven systems support cost savings route efficiency and real-time visibility into freight flows. For businesses whose supply chains depend on reliable transportation and load planning Hub is a high-value partner.
Strengths
- Extensive intermodal and drayage network across North America
- Managed transportation and freight brokerage with dedicated fleets
- Robust visibility and analytics platforms for shipment tracking and performance
- Expertise in optimizing multimodal supply chains and reducing freight costs
- Longstanding relationships with major carriers and railroads
Key Considerations
- Does not offer pick-pack or DTC services
- No kitting or subscription box capabilities
- Warehousing services are minimal and typically used to support freight programs
What They Do Best
Hub Group is a strategic partner for enterprise clients seeking to improve their freight operations and gain better control of supply chain performance. Their strength lies in transport optimization not in handling consumer products or personalized fulfillment. This makes them a valuable resource for bulk freight movement and delivery efficiency.
SEKO Logistics
SEKO Logistics headquartered in Itasca, Illinois is a global logistics provider known for its cross-border ecommerce solutions, international freight forwarding and white-glove final mile services. Their hybrid model blends technology transportation and fulfillment to support clients selling through international channels and large retail networks. SEKO’s services are particularly valuable for brands needing global reach or specialty handling such as medical equipment technology or oversized goods. Their fulfillment capabilities exist within a broader global logistics framework that prioritizes speed compliance and flexibility.
Strengths
- Global reach with customs clearance and international parcel services
- White-glove delivery options for high-value or sensitive goods
- Technology integration with cross-border marketplaces and retail platforms
- Strong international freight, forwarding and warehousing capabilities
- Specialized handling for medical electronics and high-end products
Key Considerations
- Primarily built for international and high-value shipments over high-volume subscription models
- May be costlier than traditional fulfillment for smaller ecommerce brands
- Focused more on global logistics execution than customized branding or kitting
What They Do Best
SEKO Logistics excels at bridging the gap between international shipping and last-mile delivery. Their ability to move products quickly and compliantly across borders sets them apart from regionally focused fulfillment partners. While they offer warehousing and pick-pack services their true value lies in supporting global brands with complex logistics requirements not in delivering curated unboxing experiences.
Murphy Warehouse Company
Murphy Warehouse Company operates out of Aurora, Illinois with a strong emphasis on regulated warehousing and industrial logistics. They specialize in hazmat chemical and food-grade storage with facilities designed for compliance with strict federal and state regulations. Their services cater to businesses that require long-term pallet storage and bulk inventory control. Murphy’s model supports industrial manufacturers and regulated product suppliers who need secure facilities precise handling and documentation that aligns with safety and environmental protocols.
Strengths
- Specialized facilities for hazmat chemical and food-grade products
- Long-term pallet storage with strict compliance protocols
- Experience handling environmentally sensitive and regulated goods
- Secure warehouses with advanced monitoring and controlled access
- Established provider for industrial and government contracts
Key Considerations
- Not equipped for high-volume DTC or fast-turn ecommerce operations
- Limited in custom packaging kitting or consumer-facing branding
- More appropriate for static storage and industrial logistics than active fulfillment
What They Do Best
Murphy Warehouse Company is built for clients whose logistics needs center around safety, security and compliance. Their expertise in storing regulated materials and managing industrial inventories offers stability and peace of mind.
Capstone Logistics
Capstone Logistics based in Chicago focuses on high-efficiency freight brokerage and managed transportation. Their strength lies in optimizing full truckload and less-than-truckload routes for food beverage and consumer packaged goods companies. With a technology-first approach Capstone combines real-time visibility with carrier management to support on-time performance and cost control. Their services are well suited for brands that move large volumes of product across regional or national routes but do not require warehouse storage or order-level fulfillment.
Strengths
- Expertise in full truckload and LTL transportation management
- Real-time shipment tracking and logistics analytics
- Network of vetted carriers with strong on-time delivery performance
- Specialized services for food beverage and CPG supply chains
- Freight optimization focused on route efficiency and cost savings
Key Considerations
- Not a warehousing or pick-pack fulfillment provider
- No support for custom packaging or consumer-facing experiences
- Primarily focused on freight coordination rather than end-customer deliver
What They Do Best
Capstone Logistics through LoadDelivered is ideal for businesses that require efficient freight management rather than order-level fulfillment. They bring transparency and performance to transportation operations helping clients reduce costs and increase delivery reliability.
RJW Logistics Group
RJW Logistics Group headquartered in Woodridge, Illinois has built its reputation around retail consolidation and vendor compliance services for consumer goods companies. Their core strength lies in efficiently delivering full truckload shipments to retail distribution centers particularly for brands selling through Walmart, Target and other big-box chains. With a vertically integrated model that combines warehousing transportation and retail routing expertise RJW helps reduce inventory lead times and ensure compliance with complex retailer standards. Their model supports high-volume replenishment for retail shelves not individualized order fulfillment.
Strengths
- Specialization in retail pool distribution and consolidated freight
- Deep expertise in routing guide compliance for big-box retailers
- Integrated warehousing and transportation model for replenishment logistics
- Systems built to support retail shelf availability and forecast accuracy
- Scalable model for mid-sized and enterprise CPG brands
Strengths
- Expertise in full truckload and LTL transportation management
- Real-time shipment tracking and logistics analytics
- Network of vetted carriers with strong on-time delivery performance
- Specialized services for food beverage and CPG supply chains
- Freight optimization focused on route efficiency and cost savings
Key Considerations
- Not designed for direct-to-consumer fulfillment or customized order handling
- Minimal focus on branding packaging or unboxing experience
- Primarily built for brands with strong retail channel presence and truckload volume
What They Do Best
RJW Logistics Group performs exceptionally well for consumer brands that need precise and efficient delivery into major retail networks. Their retail consolidation model reduces complexity and improves shelf performance for CPG companies.
Ready to work with a 3PL that prioritizes precision, partnership, and performance? Let’s talk about how Badger Fulfillment Group can help you scale with confidence.
